PJM Utilities Restrict Smart Meter Data, Starving Virtual Power Plants of Vital Inputs
A $6 billion investment in 12 million smart meters across the PJM Interconnection is failing to deliver promised grid flexibility. According to a FERC complaint, utilities are restricting data access, effectively stranding gigawatts of potential virtual power plant capacity.
Across the 13-state PJM Interconnection, a $6 billion investment in 12 million smart meters has failed to provide the digital foundation expected for a flexible grid. According to a complaint filed with the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) last October by Voltus and the Mission:data Coalition, utilities are withholding the granular consumption data required for third-party demand-response providers to function. While these meters were intended to help customers save money and curb rising energy demand, they have created a data bottleneck that complicates, rather than enables, the participation of virtual power plants (VPPs) in wholesale energy and capacity markets.
PJM is currently navigating an energy crisis characterized by surging demand from data centers and a grid-interconnection bottleneck that has slowed the arrival of new generation. Independent analysts and market participants argue that VPPs and demand-response programs are critical to alleviating these pressures. However, according to Emily Orvis, vice president of energy markets at Voltus, the current regulatory environment assumes that smart meter data is accessible to aggregators, even when it is not. This creates a scenario where it is ironically easier to manage older, electromechanical meters using statistical sampling than to utilize the data from modern smart meters.
The FERC complaint details how utilities have implemented administrative hurdles that render data access effectively impossible. Some utilities require data requests to be submitted in batches of ten, while others force customers to initiate individual email requests, resulting in wait times of two to four weeks. At Chicago-area utility Commonwealth Edison, Voltus reported that it was able to enroll only 4% of its customers through the utility's system, resulting in approximately 23 megawatts of stranded capacity. For large commercial and industrial clients, Voltus can install proprietary meter-reading equipment, but this approach is not cost-effective for residential or small commercial customers who require an efficient, programmatic data pipeline.
Utilities have defended their data policies by citing legal responsibilities regarding consumer privacy and cybersecurity. However, critics argue these justifications are a pretext for maintaining market dominance. A December report from Mission:data and the Open Markets Institute asserts that utilities are using meter data as a competitive weapon to protect their monopoly relationships with customers, as they often operate their own competing demand-response programs. Chris Villarreal, an associate fellow at the R Street Institute, noted in a November blog post that the lack of standardized data access rules remains a primary impediment to customer choice and the development of new energy markets.
Utilities named in the complaint, including Exelon—which owns ComEd, PECO, and other regional providers—along with New Jersey’s PSE&G and Pennsylvania’s Duquesne Light, maintain that they are simply complying with state-level laws and regulations. In comments filed with FERC, Exelon suggested that the concerns raised by Voltus and Mission:data should be directed toward state public utility commissions rather than federal regulators. According to Michael Murray, president of Mission:data, this highlights a broader issue: while over a dozen states have ordered utilities to build digital tools for data sharing, most utilities continue to keep data locked behind incompatible formats and byzantine enrollment systems.
Sources
- 01 Utilities aren’t sharing smart meter data in PJM. That’s a problem. — Canary Media