Northeast States Sue Over $795 Million Federal Buyout of Offshore Wind Leases
A seven-state coalition is suing the Department of the Interior to block a deal paying TotalEnergies $795 million to abandon a 3-gigawatt offshore wind project.
A coalition of seven Democratic-led Northeast states filed a federal lawsuit on Tuesday against the U.S. Department of the Interior, challenging a controversial agreement to pay French energy giant TotalEnergies to abandon its offshore wind projects. According to Canary Media, the deal involves the federal government reimbursing TotalEnergies $795 million for lease fees it paid for a massive development area off the coasts of New York and New Jersey. The states, led by New York Attorney General Letitia James, characterize the arrangement as an unlawful attempt to dismantle clean energy infrastructure and destroy regional jobs.
The legal challenge, filed in the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia, includes New York, New Jersey, Connecticut, Maine, Massachusetts, Rhode Island, and Vermont. These states argue that the cancellation of the Attentive Energy project threatens their ability to meet statutory climate targets and maintain grid reliability. New England states joined the suit because they frequently import power from New York through high-voltage interconnections.
Attorneys general for the states contend that the Trump administration violated the Outer Continental Shelf Lands Act, which restricts the Interior Department's authority to cancel leases without a formal hearing to weigh public benefits. Furthermore, the lawsuit alleges a violation of the Judgment Fund Act. While the federal government used taxpayer dollars from this fund to pay TotalEnergies, the plaintiffs argue the fund is reserved for settling active litigation, which was not present in this case. TotalEnergies has reportedly pledged to redirect the $795 million toward fossil fuel projects, including LNG exports.
The Department of the Interior defended the buyout as a voluntary agreement that was reviewed and approved by the Department of Justice. A spokesperson for the department stated that the cancellation was in the public interest. However, offshore wind experts and former Interior employees cited by Canary Media have questioned the legality of the payback plan. The deal follows several other attempts by the administration to block East Coast wind farms, including separate agreements with Ocean Winds to relinquish leases near California, New York, and New Jersey totaling nearly $900 million.
For the Northeast, the loss of the Attentive Energy site creates a significant supply-side deficit. New Jersey Attorney General Jennifer Davenport noted that the state requires more power supply to prevent blackouts during extreme weather events. CleanTechnica reports that the Sierra Club has supported the litigation, calling the buyouts a politically motivated attack on the clean energy supply chain. As the case moves through the courts, the states are seeking to vacate the lease cancellation and prevent the administration from implementing further buyout deals that favor the fossil fuel industry over renewable generation.