Supreme Court Decision Ends FTC Commissioners' Independence, Expands Presidential Control

The Supreme Court ruled 6-3 in Trump v. Slaughter that the president may fire FTC commissioners at will, overturning nearly a century of legal precedent regarding agency autonomy.

Startups, Policy & World Desk
Updated 6d ago 2 min read
Supreme Court Decision Ends FTC Commissioners' Independence, Expands Presidential Control

In a landmark 6-3 decision in Trump v. Slaughter, the Supreme Court has granted the president the authority to fire Federal Trade Commission commissioners at will. According to The Verge, this ruling effectively ends the agency's status as an independent body by overturning the 1935 Humphrey’s Executor precedent. That long-standing legal standard previously dictated that commissioners of independent agencies could only be removed for cause, such as neglect of duty or malfeasance. The court has now determined that such restrictions on presidential power are unconstitutional under the principle of the unitary executive theory.

Chief Justice John Roberts, delivering the majority opinion, wrote that neither Congress nor the courts may force a president to work with subordinates with whom he cannot cooperate. According to the court's syllabus, officials who exercise executive power must be subject to removal by the president to ensure they remain accountable to the administration and, by extension, the people. The majority concluded that the framework established in the 1935 case has not withstood the test of time, asserting that independent agencies are not truly free of presidential oversight.

The ruling specifically addressed the removal of Democratic commissioners Rebecca Kelly Slaughter and Alvaro Bedoya. While Slaughter continued to pursue the legal challenge, Bedoya eventually resigned his post to seek other employment. The Verge reports that the decision may not result in immediate operational shifts, as Republican Chair Andrew Ferguson has already moved to align the agency with the executive branch. Ferguson has reportedly instructed staff to stop referring to the FTC as independent in legal filings and has publicly labeled the body the Trump-Vance Commission.

Justice Sonia Sotomayor issued a sharp dissent, joined by two other justices, arguing that the decision distorts the fundamental structure of the federal government. According to The Verge, Sotomayor wrote that the ruling grants the president an unbridled authority that was never bestowed by the Constitution, Congress, or the people. She criticized the majority for upending precedent and misconstruing history, suggesting the court has abandoned judicial modesty to expand executive power beyond its intended limits.

The implications of the Slaughter ruling extend to other bodies previously considered independent, including the Federal Communications Commission, Federal Election Commission, National Labor Relations Board, and National Transportation Safety Board. However, the court did not apply this logic universally. In a separate 5-4 ruling, the justices determined that Congress could still permit removal only for cause at the Federal Reserve. This distinction suggests that while the FTC is now firmly under presidential control, certain financial regulatory structures may retain their existing protections for the time being.

President Trump celebrated the decision on Truth Social, stating that 90 years of precedent had been completely and unequivocally overruled. He characterized the expansion of presidential power as a necessary development for the current era. As the FTC transitions into a direct arm of the administration, the ruling signals a major shift in how antitrust and consumer protection laws will be enforced, moving away from the autonomous model that has defined the agency for nearly a century.

Sources

  1. 01 Supreme Court allows firing of FTC commissioners, ends agency independence — The Verge — Policy