SCREEN Act's Broad Age Verification Mandate Threatens Universal Online Privacy
The Senate Commerce Committee is considering S. 737, the SCREEN Act, which would mandate invasive age verification for online services hosting sexually explicit material, threatening user privacy and anonymity.
The Senate Commerce Committee is set to consider S. 737, known as the SCREEN Act, according to EFF Deeplinks. The sweeping age-verification bill would require online services to verify users' ages before granting access to any sexually explicit content. If passed, the legislation would force millions of adult internet users to surrender their anonymity, privacy, and security before accessing lawful speech.
Unlike many state-level age verification laws, the SCREEN Act lacks any requirement that a significant portion of a website consist of sexually explicit content harmful to minors, according to the report. Instead, the bill mandates that nearly any service hosting even a single piece of sexually explicit content must verify user ages. This broad scope means the legislation would apply to adult platforms alongside streaming services like Netflix and social media networks such as Reddit, Discord, or Bluesky.
The SCREEN Act explicitly states that requiring a user to confirm they are not a minor is insufficient for compliance. According to EFF Deeplinks, this practical reality means platforms would have to implement age verification methods tied to real identities, compelling users to submit personal data to digital verification services that capture and store the information in databases.
The publication notes that the legislation creates a severe privacy and data security risk. While the bill includes provisions requiring services to take reasonable steps to protect collected data and avoid retaining it longer than necessary, these requirements impose weak protections without meaningful collection, use, or retention limits.
Consequently, third parties tasked with verifying user ages could collect excessive personal information and retain it for extended periods. Companies would be permitted to keep data compelled from users so long as they deem their actions reasonable, raising profound security concerns regarding pervasive personal data harvesting.
Furthermore, the SCREEN Act targets virtual private network users and providers by requiring covered websites to verify ages based on IP addresses unless a service determines a user is outside the United States. The legislation specifically mandates age verification on traffic originating from known VPN addresses, effectively discouraging tools that millions rely on for cybersecurity, privacy, and protecting journalists or activists.
Sources
- 01 The SCREEN Act Threatens Privacy Far Beyond Adult Websites — EFF Deeplinks