Lyft Settles Landmark Driver Misclassification Suit for $272.5 Million
California officials have reached a $272.5 million settlement with Lyft to resolve allegations of driver misclassification occurring between 2016 and 2020.
California’s attorney general and three city attorneys have secured a $272.5 million settlement with Lyft, resolving allegations that the company committed wage theft by misclassifying drivers as independent contractors between 2016 and 2020. According to a statement released on Thursday, the agreement concludes litigation initiated in May 2020 by then-Attorney General Xavier Becerra, who sued both Uber and Lyft for evading state law regarding employee status. While this settlement addresses the claims against Lyft, the legal action against Uber remains ongoing.
The core of the dispute centered on Assembly Bill 5 (AB5), a state law that established a three-part test to determine worker classification. Attorney General Rob Bonta described the resolution as a landmark win for workers, stating that rideshare companies have historically achieved growth on the backs of drivers, many from immigrant communities and communities of color. Los Angeles City Attorney Hydee Feldstein Soto added that the settlement serves as a warning, noting that when companies misclassify workers, they deny them critical protections and shift the financial burden onto taxpayers.
The scope of the settlement is strictly limited to the 2016-2020 period due to the passage of Proposition 22 in November 2020. That ballot measure, which was organized primarily by Uber and Lyft, granted ride-hailing companies an exemption to the requirements of AB5. Consequently, the legal claims in this specific suit do not extend beyond the timeframe prior to the enactment of the new law. The settlement effectively closes the chapter on those specific years of contested labor practices while leaving the current regulatory framework established by Proposition 22 intact.
Lyft CEO David Risher defended the company’s historical practices in a statement provided to Ars Technica, asserting that Lyft believes drivers have always been properly classified under the law. Risher pointed to the 2020 vote as evidence that the vast majority of drivers prefer independent contractor status, which preserves their flexibility. He further noted that the company has implemented additional measures, such as a fee cap, which he described as going beyond the requirements mandated by Proposition 22. Risher stated that the company is glad to put this case behind them.
Critics of the settlement argue that the financial penalty is insufficient given the scale of the alleged violations. Veena Dubal, a law professor at the University of California, Irvine, characterized the $272.5 million figure as a paltry sum compared to the total wages owed to thousands of low-income, mostly immigrant and racial-minority workers. She argued that the settlement does not adequately compensate for the funds that would have otherwise gone to rent and food for families. Meanwhile, labor organizing continues, with the state’s labor board recently recognizing the California Gig Workers Union following legislation signed last year.
Sources
- 01 Lyft settles landmark driver misclassification lawsuit for $272.5M — Ars Technica — Policy