FTC Faces Pressure to Deny X Corp’s Request to End Privacy Reporting Requirements
X Corp. is petitioning the Federal Trade Commission to terminate a 2022 consent decree regarding data privacy, arguing that corporate restructuring and new leadership warrant an end to oversight. Privacy advocates are urging the FTC to reject the request.
On May 15, X Corp. filed a petition with the Federal Trade Commission requesting that the agency set aside or modify a 2022 consent decree that mandates regular reporting on the company's privacy and data security compliance. The order, which requires X to submit to independent audits and provides the FTC with authority to demand documents, stems from a 2011 settlement regarding the misuse of user contact information for targeted advertising. According to Ars Technica, the company argues that the order is no longer necessary due to significant corporate restructuring, rebranding, and the fact that it faces similar obligations under the European Union’s General Data Protection Regulation.
A coalition of 15 privacy and consumer protection organizations, including the Electronic Frontier Foundation, the Electronic Privacy Information Center, and the National Consumers League, has formally urged the FTC to reject the petition. In a letter submitted ahead of a July 2 deadline, the groups argued that "X Corp.’s petition fails to clear the demanding legal standard necessary to grant the extraordinary action the corporation is requesting." The advocates contend that the company's current leadership presents a "serious risk to Americans’ privacy and data security," asserting that the FTC must maintain its role as a deterrent against repeat offenders.
In its filing, X claims that it has "built an entirely new privacy and information security program staffed by new personnel operating under new leadership with a … philosophy grounded on the importance of privacy and information security." The company further argues that the oversight requirements are duplicative and burdensome, claiming that "terminating the Order is critical to advancing American leadership in artificial intelligence." X asserts that the compliance measures divert engineering resources away from innovation, specifically regarding its AI development efforts, rather than serving as a necessary safeguard for user information.
Advocates strongly dispute the claim that X’s entry into AI justifies a reduction in oversight. According to the Electronic Frontier Foundation, the company’s integration of its Grok AI model in 2024, which was trained on user data "without meaningful consent," highlights the risks of secondary data use. Furthermore, the coalition noted that the platform suffered a massive data breach in 2025, involving 2.8 billion records. The EFF also dismissed X’s claims of financial hardship, noting in its letter that compliance costs are merely "a rounding error against the $200 billion valuation of X Corp. following the xAI merger."
While the coalition opposes the petition, former U.S. Attorney General William Barr has submitted comments in support of X. Barr criticized the FTC’s information demands following the acquisition of the platform as excessive, arguing against "permanent agency control of private companies." He urged the commission to stop treating the termination of consent orders as an extraordinary event. However, advocates argue that X’s legal analysis is "misleading," noting that the order is only four years old and that the company has failed to provide valid legal precedents to support its request for termination.
Sources
- 01 EFF and Allies: X’s FTC Petition to Waive Privacy Violation Order Should be Rejected — EFF Deeplinks
- 02 Musk’s X poses “serious risk to Americans’ privacy,” advocates warn FTC — Ars Technica — Policy