Federal Data Consolidation Threatens Privacy Through Unlawful Silos
According to EFF Deeplinks, the federal government has unlawfully consolidated citizen data in three rolling waves involving DOGE, ICE data sharing, and voter roll purges.
Over the past two years, the federal government has unlawfully consolidated data exposing private information, according to EFF Deeplinks. This consolidation occurred in three rolling waves starting with DOGE, moving to agency-to-agency data sharing with ICE, and attempting data-driven purges of state voter rolls. Combining this information together results in errors, misconduct, and a loss of confidence in institutions, chilling participation in society, particularly for groups disfavored by the administration such as immigrants and protesters.
Beginning on January 20, 2025, President Trump created DOGE, which quickly obtained high-level access to sensitive databases storing millions of personal records at the Office of Personnel Management (OPM), the Social Security Administration (SSA), and the Treasury Department. Staffed with individuals lacking government or cybersecurity knowledge, DOGE aimed for prompt access to unclassified agency records and their consolidation. This resulted in the indiscriminate firing of government employees and clear misuses of data, including an SSA individual signing an outside agreement to use data to find evidence of alleged voter fraud.
DOGE's data access and consolidation violated the federal Privacy Act. Groups including the Electronic Frontier Foundation and co-counsel Lex Lumina LLC and Democracy Defenders Fund sued the OPM on behalf of public employee unions AFGE and AALJ. After securing early victories, the government sought to end lawsuits by firing many DOGE agents and removing their access to records, though a great deal of damage remains.
Even as DOGE's influence diminished, federal agencies attempted to share, compare, and seize large databases to target immigrants. This included tax records at the IRS, Medicaid data from the Department of Health and Human Services, and public housing data from the Department of Housing and Urban Development, while the Department of Agriculture sought Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program databases from states. Lawsuits have been filed to block this data consolidation, including Centro de Trabajadores v. Bessent regarding IRS data and California v. HHS regarding Medicaid data.
Data consolidation for immigration enforcement also involved purchasing commercial products, such as ICE buying commercial location data without a warrant and contracting with companies like Palantir. Additionally, the federal government has attempted to purge voters by consolidating data in three ways: using the Systematic Alien Verification for Entitlements (SAVE) system for checking voter eligibility, seizing voter information from states, and creating a federal list of eligible voters.
Operated since 1986, SAVE facilitates easy access to databases to determine benefit eligibility. In 2025, the government started using SAVE to check voter eligibility, running more than 60 million voters through the system and flagging 21,000 as potential noncitizens, which caused purges of lawful voters such as Anthony Nell. A case titled League of Women Voters v. DHS challenges this expansion, where a federal judge held the program unlawful before the U.S. Supreme Court later granted a stay by a six-to-three vote.
Sources
- 01 Resisting the Menace of Federal Data Consolidation — EFF Deeplinks