EU Court Ruling Expands Platform Liability, Raising Risks for Online Expression
A new EU Court of Justice ruling in Coyote System threatens to strip online platforms of liability protections by equating algorithmic curation with content control, potentially incentivizing widespread censorship of user speech.
The European Union Court of Justice has issued a ruling in Coyote System (Joined Cases C-188/24 and C-190/24) that threatens to erode long-standing liability protections for online platforms. According to the Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF), the judgment introduces a broad new test for when an intermediary loses its neutral status. By ruling that an intermediary controls information if its algorithm determines "under what conditions, how and in which order of priority" content is disseminated, the Court has potentially stripped platforms of the hosting liability exemptions previously guaranteed under the e-Commerce Directive and the Digital Services Act (DSA).
While the case specifically concerned navigation systems that relay real-time roadside check information, the EFF warns that the Court’s reasoning is not limited to that narrow application. Recommendation algorithms, which are fundamental to how social media platforms and search engines organize user content, could now be interpreted as evidence of control. The EFF argues that if this interpretation holds, the hosting liability exemption—designed to prevent platforms from being forced to proactively monitor and filter user speech—could become "largely meaningless" for major digital services like Facebook or Amazon.
Historically, the "active role" that disqualified a platform from liability protection was understood to relate to the content itself, rather than the technical systems used to organize it. The EFF notes that previous case law, such as YouTube and Cyando, established that categorizing or ranking content did not automatically remove a platform's immunity. The Advocate General in that matter emphasized that the relevant test is "intellectual control of that content," not merely the technical arrangement of information. Coyote System marks a "dangerous change of emphasis" by conflating algorithmic organization with the exercise of editorial control over user-provided information.
This ruling appears to contradict the structure of the Digital Services Act, which regulates recommendation algorithms through due diligence obligations while maintaining the foundational hosting liability regime. The EFF points out that during the negotiation of the DSA, proposals to remove liability protections for platforms that optimize or promote content were explicitly rejected. The Court’s decision fails to address why intermediary liability exists or the fundamental rights it protects, instead focusing on the specific nature of the navigation service, which the Advocate General described as creating a new "information layer."
The EFF characterizes this decision as part of a troubling trend where the Court of Justice has gradually narrowed intermediary liability protections. Recent rulings, such as Russmedia and AGCOM, have increasingly prioritized preventive content control over the safeguarding of user privacy and free expression. There is also a significant political risk, as the European Commission has previously used such landmark rulings to justify legislative changes that further restrict rights. If this trajectory continues, the EFF warns that freedom of expression online risks becoming "collateral damage" in the EU's evolving regulatory landscape.